Buttermilk Scones with Strawberries and Milk Chocolate Chunks

Saturday, February 28, 2009 40 Comments

Over the Christmas holidays, my sweetie took me on an exciting trip to the big city, NYC. We walked and walked and walked, and we ate and ate and ate, (and we froze and froze and froze). I made the mistake of bringing only my Vancouver-weather rubber boots to stomp around in. Did you know that uninsulated rubber boots act as individual foot refrigerators in cold weather, the way they trap and recirculate damp, frigid air? So because of my silly choice of footwear, we froze. And because we froze, we ate – for every few blocks we walked, we had to stop in somewhere to warm up. We found all kinds of little hole-in-the wall shops and cafes where we were happy to munch on cupcakes, rice pudding, cardamom coffee, dosas, thin-crust pizzas… As far as problems go, this one was rather favorable, the freezing necessitating the eating – my tummy was happy enough to more than make up for my toes’ misery.

One of my favorite places we stumbled into to thaw our extremities was a little tea house called Alice’s Tea Cup in the upper west side. The entrance was just like a descent into the rabbit hole, and the inside was magically decorated with twinkly lights, keyhole windows, stained glass, and antiques. They had a multiple-page menu of teas and a selection of sweets to accompany them, including a variety of fresh scones with cream and fruit preserves. I hungrily devoured a warm strawberry-chocolate scone, piled with sweet whipped cream. And it was so scrumptious that it has been on my mind ever since.

scones1 Buttermilk Scones with Strawberries and Milk Chocolate Chunks

Happily, the ones I recreated in my kitchen were every bit as delicious as I hoped they’d be. I found some gorgeous, flavourful strawberries at the market, which is rare around here except for about 6 weeks in the summer. They lended themselves beautifully to a fluffy, lightly sweetened scone, with chunks of milk chocolate that put it over the moon. Served warm with a spoonful of creme fraiche, they are absolutely dreamy.

scones Buttermilk Scones with Strawberries and Milk Chocolate Chunks

Buttermilk Scones with Strawberries and Milk Chocolate Chunks

Adapted from “Our Finest Buttermilk Scones” in The Canadian Living Baking Book

  • 2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 tbsp sugar
  • 1 1/2 tsp baking powder
  • 1/2 tsp baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1/2 cup cold butter, cubed
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • 1 egg
  • 3/4 cup hulled, sliced strawberries
  • 1/2 cup milk chocolate chunks

1. Line a large, rimless baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside. Preheat oven to 400 degrees.

2. In large bowl, whisk together flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Using pastry blender, or two knives, cut in butter until crumbly. In separate bowl, whisk buttermilk with egg. Pour over flour mixture. Stir with fork to make a soft, ragged dough. With a wooden spoon, gently mix in strawberries and chocolate chunks.

3. With lightly floured hands, press dough into ball. On floured surface, knead gently ten times. Pat out into a 10 x 7-inch rectangle. Cut rectangle into 4 squares, and cut each diagonally in half to make 8 triangles. Place on prepared pan. Bake in center of oven until golden, 15-18 minutes. Transfer to rack and let cool.

  • http://www.fearlesskitchen.com Fearless Kitchen

    This looks wonderful! Chocolate and strawberries make such a great combination.

  • http://www.fearlesskitchen.com Fearless Kitchen

    This looks wonderful! Chocolate and strawberries make such a great combination.

  • http://closetcooking.blogspot.com/ Kevin

    I really like the sound of adding chocolate and strawberries to buttermilk scones…mmm…

  • http://closetcooking.blogspot.com/ Kevin

    I really like the sound of adding chocolate and strawberries to buttermilk scones…mmm…

  • http://maplencornbread.blogspot.com/ Jennifer

    Fabulous idea!!!

  • http://maplencornbread.blogspot.com/ Jennifer

    Fabulous idea!!!

  • http://www.sophiesfoodiefiles.blogspot.com Sophie

    MMMMMM…those scones look superb!!! It is making me hungry!!!

  • http://www.sophiesfoodiefiles.blogspot.com Sophie

    MMMMMM…those scones look superb!!! It is making me hungry!!!

  • nicola

    these were amazing! thanks for the scone jenn!

  • nicola

    these were amazing! thanks for the scone jenn!

  • Lesa

    When does the baking soda go in? I don’t see that the recipe mentions it after the list of ingredients. I put it in with the baking powder. The dough was really kind of wet and sticky. I had to add at least another half cup of flour. Not sure why. The scones are in the oven now. They are puffing up nicely. Need to correct the directions to include (or exclude) the baking soda though!

  • Lesa

    When does the baking soda go in? I don’t see that the recipe mentions it after the list of ingredients. I put it in with the baking powder. The dough was really kind of wet and sticky. I had to add at least another half cup of flour. Not sure why. The scones are in the oven now. They are puffing up nicely. Need to correct the directions to include (or exclude) the baking soda though!

  • http://www.foodess.com foodess

    Thanks for pointing that out, Lesa. It should be corrected now. And it is normal for the dough to be wet and sticky, just keep the counter and your hands floured while working with it, and they’ll turn out fine.

  • http://www.foodess.com foodess

    Thanks for pointing that out, Lesa. It should be corrected now. And it is normal for the dough to be wet and sticky, just keep the counter and your hands floured while working with it, and they’ll turn out fine.

  • Natasha

    Tried them last weekend, and what a hit! They look just like yours, thanks soooo much!

  • Natasha

    Tried them last weekend, and what a hit! They look just like yours, thanks soooo much!

  • meagan

    These were amazing!!! I did replace 1/2 c. flour with pastry flour. I made mine with frozen raspberries and dark chocolate chips. I sprinkled the dough with these before each fold (instead of kneading I folded the dough) and then put the dough in the fridge for 10 minutes before cutting. Mine baked for 19 minutes and looked just like yours. They were sweet and salty and light, not very dense.

  • meagan

    These were amazing!!! I did replace 1/2 c. flour with pastry flour. I made mine with frozen raspberries and dark chocolate chips. I sprinkled the dough with these before each fold (instead of kneading I folded the dough) and then put the dough in the fridge for 10 minutes before cutting. Mine baked for 19 minutes and looked just like yours. They were sweet and salty and light, not very dense.

  • http://www.dessertobsessed.wordpress.com DessertObsessed

    I love Alice’s Tea Cup! They have the best scones. I didn’t get to try the strawberry ones though… but I’ll definitely try your recipe!

  • http://www.dessertobsessed.wordpress.com DessertObsessed

    I love Alice’s Tea Cup! They have the best scones. I didn’t get to try the strawberry ones though… but I’ll definitely try your recipe!

  • http://cupcakemuffin.blogspot.com sara

    YUM! These look gorgeous and delicious. :)

  • http://cupcakemuffin.blogspot.com sara

    YUM! These look gorgeous and delicious. :)

  • Amy

    I live in a suburb of NYC and go to Alice’s Teacup several times a year. I was looking for a recipe for strawberry chocolate scones because I could not make it into the city and wanted to try to make them at home. I was thrilled when I found this recipe! The scones were quite delicious!!! The only difference I could tell was that these were a little less light and fluffy but great nonetheless!!!

  • Amy

    I live in a suburb of NYC and go to Alice’s Teacup several times a year. I was looking for a recipe for strawberry chocolate scones because I could not make it into the city and wanted to try to make them at home. I was thrilled when I found this recipe! The scones were quite delicious!!! The only difference I could tell was that these were a little less light and fluffy but great nonetheless!!!

  • http://teaandcomfort.blogspot.com Noel

    I just tried this recipe, and it’s FANTASTIC. There was no oven temperature, so I just set it to 400F like I usually do.
    I also didn’t have strawberries, but just chocolate chips were enough.

    These are absolutely FANTASTIC, with the same sweet, moist flavor that I loved so much at Alice’s Tea Cup!

  • http://teaandcomfort.blogspot.com Noel

    I just tried this recipe, and it’s FANTASTIC. There was no oven temperature, so I just set it to 400F like I usually do.
    I also didn’t have strawberries, but just chocolate chips were enough.

    These are absolutely FANTASTIC, with the same sweet, moist flavor that I loved so much at Alice’s Tea Cup!

  • http://lane44walker.easyjournal.com breenxithylon@gmail.com

    Heya – Nice site, just checking around some pages, seems to be a quite nice platform you are running here. I’m now using WordPress to run some of my web sites but trying to switch one of these over to a platform similar to yours just for a trial run. Anything in particular you would suggest about it?

  • http://lane44walker.easyjournal.com breenxithylon@gmail.com

    Heya – Nice site, just checking around some pages, seems to be a quite nice platform you are running here. I’m now using WordPress to run some of my web sites but trying to switch one of these over to a platform similar to yours just for a trial run. Anything in particular you would suggest about it?

  • http://sarahvannuys.wordpress.com/2010/05/15/scones-scones-scones/ Scones, scones, scones « The Process of Domestication

    [...] (Strawberries and spinach. Amazing.) Scones were an obvious choice. My first batch was based on this recipe (except I used dark chocolate). Uh, wow. Incredible. Why did I wait so long to make buttermilk [...]

  • Emily

    These are in the oven right now and look so good – I went with 1/2 c fresh strawberries, and 1/2 cup frozen blueberries. The dough was way too wet to work with, so I ended up lightly working in nearly another cup of flour when working the dough. Maybe this is because of the fruit? Also, the recipe states to cut into rectangles, but the picture shows triangles — how many scones did you end up with? I did two small circles and cut them into quarters. I can’t wait to try one!

  • Emily

    These are in the oven right now and look so good – I went with 1/2 c fresh strawberries, and 1/2 cup frozen blueberries. The dough was way too wet to work with, so I ended up lightly working in nearly another cup of flour when working the dough. Maybe this is because of the fruit? Also, the recipe states to cut into rectangles, but the picture shows triangles — how many scones did you end up with? I did two small circles and cut them into quarters. I can’t wait to try one!

  • Vir

    The scons are delicious!! I’m very happy of finding someone who loves them too and also to have the recipie!!! I tried them at Alice and I loved them!! Alice was for sure my favourite place in NY!!! Woww!!!

  • Vir

    The scons are delicious!! I’m very happy of finding someone who loves them too and also to have the recipie!!! I tried them at Alice and I loved them!! Alice was for sure my favourite place in NY!!! Woww!!!

  • tina

    hi! this looks reaaally great and i’d love to try it out. do you have the portions in metric units?
    love your website!

  • tina

    hi! this looks reaaally great and i’d love to try it out. do you have the portions in metric units?
    love your website!

  • http://anjeme.blogspot.com Anni

    Ooooh these look fabulous! I was on a total scone kick last winter and can’t wait for the temperature to drop so I can start baking again. I’m absolutely going to have to make a batch with strawberries and chocolate chips… thanks for the inspiration!

  • Anonymous

    You won’t be disappointed :-) And it might even be worth turning on the oven while it’s still crazy to do so…

  • http://seductivesweets.wordpress.com/2011/05/11/strawberry-chocolate-chunk-scones/ Strawberry Chocolate Chunk Scones « seductivesweets

    [...] This recipe is an adaptation from Jenn’s Foodess.com recipe. [...]

  • Jaelynn

    I’ve made this recipe before to make the ‘proper’ strawberry/chocolate scones and they turned out amazingly! So when today when I was asked to bake some scones for a little bake sale I immediately thought of yours. I used chocolate chips instead of full chunks and a small 3cm cookie cutter to make little circles — they’re still wonderfully fluffy and delicious and I just simply had to thank you for this brilliant snack recipe :)

  • Anonymous

    Thank you so much for the comment Jaelynn!! Glad you liked!!